Views And Reviews: In The South
...However, following the première of The Apostles, he holidayed on the Italian Riviera. Amid the sunshine and scenery was born the concert overture In the South (1904). Did the locale remind Elgar of Strauss's Aus Italien (1886)? If so, it would explain the sudden resurrection of that sonic kinship. In focusing on the opening's similarity to Don Juan, many commentators implicitly admit a blinkered view: throughout, Elgar breathes the very same air as Strauss...
Perceptive critic Paul Serotsky introduces us to Elgar’s overture In the South.
To read more of Paul’s entertaining and informative words on the greatest music ever written please click on http://www.openwriting.com/archives/views_and_reviews/
Elgar (1857-1934) – Overture: In the South (Alassio)
Part of Elgar's magic is his facility with music on both the grandest scale and the most intimate. At one end are nobility and profound spirituality, at the other melodic felicity and disarming good humour. Bridging – and blurring – the boundary between the two is his consummate craftsmanship, bestowed equally on works both great and small. That the two become ideally balanced in his medium-scale works probably explains the extraordinary appeal of Cockaigne, the Introduction and Allegro, and Alassio. His voice is unique, owing nothing to anybody. Or does it?
Well, perhaps a little to Schumann, from whom he inherited an ability to “roll” his arguments, and maybe to Brahms for the solidity of his structures. Then again, back then, who wasn't just a bit influenced by Wagner's looming shadow? However, it surely cannot be coincidence that Froissart (1890), Elgar's first orchestral work, shared to a remarkable degree the sound-world of Richard Strauss, whose flurry of early symphonic poems was taking Europe by storm. This influence (if such it be) was rapidly submerged by Elgar's own flurry of oratorios and the more parochial nature of his succeeding orchestral works.
However, following the première of The Apostles, he holidayed on the Italian Riviera. Amid the sunshine and scenery was born the concert overture In the South (1904). Did the locale remind Elgar of Strauss's Aus Italien (1886)? If so, it would explain the sudden resurrection of that sonic kinship. In focusing on the opening's similarity to Don Juan, many commentators implicitly admit a blinkered view: throughout, Elgar breathes the very same air as Strauss.
Another point of commonality is textural complexity. From the outset, Elgar's valiant main theme breeds like nobody's business. The purported structural similarity with Cockaigne is obscured by the lack of any emphatic “big march tune” punctuation marks. Instead, Elgar punctuates using muted, wistful episodes, the first of which links the long working out of the first subject to the arching second (main) subject.
The second episode opens the development section, which climaxes on alternations of imposing, brass-dominated statements with stabbing downwardly-arpeggiated figures. Emerging from a warm haze on an entrancing solo viola, the third also forms the heart of the work, and leads directly into the reprise, varied and blended into the refulgent coda. By, it must have been some holiday!
© Paul Serotsky
